AI is changing the game: How to rethink consumer engagement?

One of the biggest challenges for marketers today is the shift in consumer behaviour, particularly in how people engage with content. This shift is largely driven by AI and the rapidly evolving digital landscape. With AI-powered algorithms prioritising zero-click experiences—where users get answers directly on platforms without ever needing to visit a website—and the rise of walled gardens like social media feeds, marketers are finding it increasingly difficult to drive engagement. AI has transformed how people discover, consume, and interact with content, forcing businesses to rethink their strategies to effectively reach and engage with consumers in these new, controlled environments.

 

6 Ways how change is playing out and why it’s such a significant challenge for marketers

Here’s how this change is playing out and why it’s such a significant challenge for marketers.

 

1. The decline of traditional search and click-through engagement

AI-powered algorithms on search engines and social media platforms now deliver answers and content directly to users, often without them having to click through to websites. This “zero-click” behaviour means that driving traffic to owned media like websites and blogs has become more difficult. Consumers expect quick, bite-sized content, and they often consume it passively on the platforms they are already using, rather than actively seeking it out.

2. Algorithm-driven content consumption

With AI curating personalised feeds on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok, consumers engage more with content that algorithms predict will interest them, rather than content they actively choose. This means businesses need to shift from traditional broadcast strategies to creating content that resonates within these algorithmic “walled gardens”. It’s no longer enough to just produce good content; you have to design it to perform well within the specific rules of each platform.

3. The shift from information to experiences

People no longer engage deeply with fact-based or purely informational content. AI has made it easier for consumers to get quick answers or information directly in search results or social feeds. As a result, marketers need to focus on creating experiences rather than just distributing facts. Brands must craft emotionally engaging, value-driven content that connects with audiences on a deeper level and fosters genuine interaction.

4. Shortened attention spans and content saturation

The volume of content available is overwhelming, and AI-driven content recommendations bombard consumers with choices. This has led to shortened attention spans, with people engaging with content for only seconds before scrolling past. To address this, marketers need to rethink their approach, focusing on delivering concise, engaging narratives that immediately capture attention and create an emotional connection.

5. The rise of conversational and interactive engagement

With AI advancements like chatbots, voice search, and interactive platforms, consumers now expect more conversational and interactive experiences. People want to engage with brands in real time, ask questions, and receive personalised responses. Marketers need to adopt strategies that allow for two-way conversations, whether through social media interactions, live content, or AI-powered customer service.

6. The influence of user-generated content and community engagement

Consumers increasingly trust recommendations and content from other users more than from brands themselves. User-generated content (UGC) has become a powerful tool in driving engagement because it feels more authentic and relatable. Businesses need to focus on building communities and encouraging their consumers to create and share content on their behalf, transforming their audience into advocates and storytellers.

Why businesses must rethink engagement strategies

With these changing behaviours, businesses can no longer rely on traditional tactics like pushing promotional content or simply hoping for organic reach. The content landscape is highly fragmented, and consumers are less likely to engage with traditional, one-size-fits-all content. Instead, marketers must focus on building organic, human-centred strategies that create long-lasting connections, community involvement, and interactive experiences.

What happens if businesses don’t adapt?

Businesses that fail to adapt to these new engagement strategies risk becoming irrelevant in a world where consumers demand authenticity and interaction. They may find their content going unnoticed amidst the noise. Worse, without adapting, businesses could see declining brand loyalty, lower engagement rates, and a decreasing ability to convert leads into customers.

The good news?

Marketers who embrace this shift and adapt their strategies to align with changing consumer behaviour can tap into new levels of engagement and loyalty. By focusing on organic, community-driven storytelling, creating immersive experiences, and interacting directly with their consumers, brands can stay relevant and thrive in this AI-driven content world.

In summary, AI has indeed changed how people engage with content, and marketers must now craft strategies that meet consumers where they are—whether that’s in algorithm-driven feeds, immersive experiences, or interactive conversations. Adaptation is the key to long-term success.

—